About Us
A Neighborhood Italian Kitchen in Rockaway Park
Plum Tomatoes by La Sorrentina brings a passion for traditional Italian cooking to the Rockaway Park community. Known for our welcoming atmosphere and commitment to authentic recipes, we have become a trusted local destination for Italian comfort food.
Special Offers
Order Direct for the Best Prices, Quality Service, and Menu Specials
Ordering directly supports faster service, freshly prepared meals, and access to the best available offers for pickup or delivery.
What They're Saying...
Loved by the Rockaway Park Community
The pasta dishes here taste like true homemade Italian cooking, with rich sauces and perfectly cooked portions. Everything arrived hot, well-portioned, and clearly made with care, making it feel like a restaurant-quality meal at home.
Michael R.
Plum Tomatoes has become our family’s go-to Italian spot whenever we want something comforting and reliable. The food is consistently excellent, portions are generous, and ordering for pickup is always smooth and on time.
Angela S.
Very friendly owners, amazing food! The Sicilian pizza had airy crust and excellent sweet sauce lots of pepperoni and the steak Stromboli was filled all the way through end to end and great taste! Thank you very much for your kindness! Very nice meeting you.
Jason T.
Always dependable with generous portions and great taste, whether it’s pasta, pizza, or one of their specials. It’s a place you can count on when you want classic Italian done right.
Linda P.
A solid Italian restaurant with classic flavors done right and no shortcuts. The food is satisfying, well-seasoned, and always feels freshly made.
Chris D.
Fresh food, friendly service, and easy ordering every time we place an order. It’s one of the few Italian spots we trust for both quality and consistency.